Instant Gratification of I am Charlie

Her-meneutics

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

How May Secularisms be the source of Modern sometimes Violent Fundamentalisms?

DSC00667

Why do wealthy Muslims Radicalize and Attack? 

“Giving Excuses The Terrorists haven’t asked for”

But “they hate our way of life” doesn’t answer the “why” question.

“Excuses” makes it sound like identifying reasons for radicalization excuses the violence. I don’t hear anyone saying that. Looking for causes is reasonable, prudent and wise.

The Guardian makes some assertions

Today, French jihadis heading to Syria are emerging from varied, often middle-class backgrounds, sometimes with a good education and prospects. In contrast, those aspiring to fight in Iraq 10 years ago were seen as psychologically fragile, poor and with no perspectives.

The Buttes-Chaumont group’s jihadi aspirations were directly linked to the second Iraq war in 2003. They would sit in apartments watching footage of the US-led invasion. “Everything I saw on TV, the torture in Abu Ghraib prison, all that, that’s what motivated me,” one of Kouachi’s friends told their trial.

So then we turn to the sources where we look within our cultural frame of reference. If we discard the economic question “they are poor, disenfranchised because of European racism and face a bleak marginalized future so therefore they turn to radical Islam” we find other reasons at hand.

  • Sociology: They were dispossessed, derived identity against a narrative of western, colonial racism
  • Psychology: their family life was chaotic
  • Political: this is a response to Western military action in their Holy Land (Bin Laden against US troops in Saudi Arabia) or against their kin (US invasion of Iraq).

The Dish today has links to lots of ideas.

NY Times Profile of Charlie Hebdo Attackers

These don’t have to be mutually exclusive. Confirmation bias suggests that if we find ourselves pointing in a direction we will find lots of evidence supporting and justifying the direction we’ve already decided to head into. Individuals always have their own unique mix even if we can identify broader trends.

I’d like to also suggest that there is a problem with the Western Secular formula that is illuminated by these killers.

There’s push and pull there too. Why radical Islam? 

Bringing Order to our Personal and Public Worlds Continue reading →

Posted in Culture commentary | Tagged | Leave a comment

men apologizing for their partner getting an abortion

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/camelswithhammers/2015/01/men-apologizing-for-having-abortions/

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Women waiting to have a baby

The Politics Of “Fertility Fog” Ctd

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Inviting Consumers To a Life They Don’t Think They Want

DSC01967

Blue Sky God

Last week we talked about the Blue Sky God, the God who always does what we approve of, establishes the morality that aligns with our own, whose words captivate everyone and everything. The advent of such a god, his/her/its coming out party, should be a grand spectacle that would attract the largest audience possible. This is how we imagine the world should be changed.

The angelic performance to the shepherds was a bit of a waste given the lack of credibility of the audience, but maybe long the lines of what we’re expected.

The one character that seemed to have any real clue about how a Messiah should be properly rolled out was ironically the devil.

  • Turn stones to bread: solidify your financial base,
  • Bow before the devil: cut deals with the movers and shakers
  • Leap from the pinnacle of the temple: let the masses at Jerusalem see your angel army and what they can do. Only Jesus would have an Air force! The Romans would surrender in a day!

After his baptism, after hearing Satan’s proposal for his marketing campaign, Jesus is ready to get going.

Making the Right Friends

If Jesus isn’t going to listen to the good advice given by the devil, he could perhaps take a play from Herod the Great’s successful career. Get yourself into the right circles. Go to the right schools. Make friends with the likes of Julius Caesar, Mark Anthony, Cleopatra and Octavius who would become the great Caesar Augustus.

Instead, Jesus starts attracting to himself Galileans, people from where he grew up. They don’t seem terribly educated, bright, or have much in terms of qualifications about them. What’s really strange is that they seem, the first ones especially, to simply be some of the people connected to him by family and village.

Going Viral Continue reading →

Posted in On the way to Sunday's sermon | 1 Comment

Duke does an About Face on Allowing its tower to be used by Muslims

NPR

Showing just how complicated religious pluralism is.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Evangelicals Changing Their Mind on Opposing Gay Marriage

Time

Conversation about gay marriage is no longer seen as an automatic compromise on Biblical authority. Other big-time evangelical pastors like Andy Stanley of North Point Community Church in Atlanta and Bill Hybels of Willow Creek do not go as far as Meeks, but they are talking with congregants and other evangelical leaders about how to navigate the changes they are seeing in their pews. Hybels has been meeting privately for the past year with LGBTQ congregants to learn to better understand their stories. At the Southern Baptist Convention’s three-day, October bootcamp to train more than 1,300 evangelicals to double down against gay marriage, Stanley met together with both LGBT evangelical advocates and SBC leaders for a closed-door conversation about whether their different views on gay marriage put them outside the faith. Jim Daly, president of Focus on the Family, has developed a friendship with LGBT activist Ted Trimpa and the Gill Foundation, and they are working together on topics like passing anti-human-trafficking legislation.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Nadia Bolz Weber on belief in the Virgin Birth and Confessionality

Patheos

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Why David Sessions Doesn’t Attend his Catholic Church yet what draws him to it

Sessions

The latter point might be another one in the church’s favor, a juncture at which history has turned its conservatism to radicalism. While the Catholic church’s destructive opposition to key scientific advancements should never be overlooked, the church has also perhaps been most resistant of all global institutions to the stranglehold pseudo-scientific and economic classifications increasingly place on human life. The church remains the closest thing to a massive anti-capitalist institution the world has ever seen. It is difficult to imagine Catholic education embracing the end-oriented schemes that have infected public education in the U.S.; at my own Catholic institution, we still require all undergraduates to take a broad-based humanistic curriculum that includes history, philosophy, and theology. In terms of graduate education, while general academic trends are equally applicable to Catholic universities, those universities continue to be generous supporters of the humanities, and it is simply understood that our disciplines are on equal footing with others. Even as an atheist graduate student, enduring the “crisis of the humanities” at a Catholic university makes it hard to ignore the church’s historical role as a repository of humanistic inquiry. (At Boston College, we even have some pretty sensational homegrown examples of no-holds-barred Catholic free-thinking.)

None of this, of course, is to suggest that unbelievers should head immediately to the nearest mass. The point is that political emancipation in general, and particularly resistance to the current trends that have put us on the path to ecological disaster, is an unimaginably arduous task. It’s not a job that will be accomplished by the occasional occupation, die-in, or state-sanctioned protest. Organizing political movements, especially around labor and environmental concerns, is of course an important challenge, and one that can give birth to a measure of real-world solidarity. But for countless others, whose inclinations or life situations put them at a certain remove from the activist life, solidarity remains simultaneously crucial and very difficult to find. While it is by no means clear that the answer is “yes,” the question is whether it makes strategic sense to ignore or oppose an institution as large or as favorable (in some respects) to leftist politics as the Catholic church.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

James Schaap on Church Growth

Stuff in the Basement

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment