Top Posts
- Mabel
- "The Romantic Solution" from Earnest Becker's "The Denial of Death"
- Jonathan Haidt's "Harm"free questions
- About
- Jane Eyre quote used in Tim Keller Sermon
- John Suk preaching from the Lion King
- Assessing Christendom
- YouTube and Podcasts
- Bertrand Russell's Free Man's Religion Quotations
- Jesus Parable Metaphor Kingdom Sarah McFague
Category Cloud
Blog note book review book writing CRC Culture commentary Daily Links and Notes Devotional Reflection How to become a Christian Institutional Church Link Compilations Links Missional On the way to Sunday's sermon Pastoral Identity philosophical reflection Quotations Saved Blog Comments Saved CRCVoices Posts Sermon Illustrations Sermon Outline Sermon Recordings Tech tools theological the self Tweets Uncategorized Understanding the Bible Video Wisdom YouTube Comments to RememberTag Cloud
- Abortion
- Acts
- Advent
- Advent 2014
- age of decay
- age to come
- Benedict Option
- book of Leviticus
- Calvin College
- Charles Taylor
- Christianity
- Christmas
- City Church San Francisco
- Confessional conversation
- CS Lewis
- David Brooks
- Donald Trump
- Douthat
- Dreher
- Esther
- Exodus
- faith
- Genesis
- hell
- Inspire2017
- James
- Jesus
- John Suk
- Jonathan Haidt
- Jordan Peterson
- Katy Perry
- Keller
- Kierkegaard
- King David
- King Saul
- Lent
- Leviticus
- Meme of the week
- Moses
- NT Wright
- Palm Sunday
- Pentecost
- Peter Enns
- Peter Kreeft
- Pope Francis
- Progressive Liberationism
- raising of lazarus
- RCA
- reflected self
- relational polarity
- Religion
- resurrection
- Rob Bell
- Rod Dreher
- Ryan Bell
- Skye Jethani
- SSM
- Steve Jobs
- Synod2015
- Synod2016
- the book of exodus
- The Book of Judges
- The book of Kings
- The book of Leviticus
- The Book of Luke
- the book of Numbers
- The Book of Samuel
- the Gospel of John
- The Gospel of Matthew
- The Road to Character
- the self book
- The Ten Commandments
- Tim Keller
- Tom Holland
- transgender
Twitter Feed
Tweets by paulvanderklay
Dreher commenter: Postmodernity and Secular Fundamentalism
Nothing necessarily new here, just well said.
Personally, I am an almost-anabaptist. I think that Christians (I can’t really speak for others) have been foolish to think that Western Culture and governments will do us any favors. They will pursue their own interests, apart from what traditionally religious people think. Politicians and cultural leaders will use religious language and people as long as it is useful, then jettison it at the first opportunity so that they are not tied to anything that will hold them back from possessing more power and authority. If you want an historical example, look at how the left now writes about the civil rights movement: it is seen as a secular movement that had a few religious people tagging along for the ride, not a religious movement that had some secular like-minded folks working toward the same goals.
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
Buddha and Hindu Statue Links
Might seem like a strange thread on this blog. I’m working on the second commandment. The Internet is an amazing resource.
Buddha Statues Continue reading
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
Re-evaluating 90s Abstinence Programs
Christianity Today pt 1
With all three of our go-to carrots we are calling young people with the same thing: Self-interest. We are teaching young people that the main reason for you make a particular sexual decision is directly related to whether or not it will benefit you. If we are calling them with self-interest, then according to our axiom from earlier, we are calling them to self-interest, and the problem is that self-interest in this area, will be unsustainable for most people.
The promise of future relational fulfillment, sexual satisfaction and a consequence-free life has a difficult time standing up to the reality of humans in relationships. We are broken, frail and fail with regularity. Some of those anticipated idyllic marriages—even when waited-for—will end in divorce; many will have sex lives in marriage that don’t add up to what they anticipated; some will remain single but always long for that promised relationship as the pinnacle of human love; some will be completely on the outside of the Evangelical narrative because they have no meaningful attraction to the opposite sex. It is these exceptions to the rule, these examples where what we call them with is unsustainable, that make me seriously question the entire approach.
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
David Brooks on Audrey Assad
She came to feel the legacy of millions of people who had struggled with the same feelings for thousands of years. “I still have routine brushes with agnosticism,” she says. “I still brush against the feeling that I don’t believe any of this, but the church always brings me back. …I don’t think Jesus wants to brush away the paradoxes and mysteries.”
Her lyrics dwell in the parts of Christianity she doesn’t understand. “I don’t want people to think I’ve had an easy time.” She still fights the tendency to go to extremes. “If I’d have been an atheist I’d have been the most obnoxious, Dawkins-loving atheist. I wouldn’t have been like Christopher Hitchens.”
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
Indiana report of demon possession
The disposession of Latoya Ammons | Indianapolis Star | indystar.com http://archive.indystar.com/article/20140125/NEWS/301250013/The-disposession-Latoya-Ammons
Follow up from Dreher looking for stories. http://www.theamericanconservative.com/dreher/the-boy-who-was-possessed-remembers
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
1 Comment
Rod Dreher on Evolution and Liberal Egalitarianism
http://www.theamericanconservative.com/dreher/evolution-the-culture-war/
As Sailer points out, it is perfectly possible to reconcile the spiritual and moral equality of humanity with what science tells us is true about human biological variability. The problem, I think, is that we humans are bad at this. Given the history of the 20th century, I flat-out don’t trust our species to handle the knowledge of human biodiversity without turning it into an ideology of dehumanization, racism, and at worst, genocide. Put another way, I am hostile to this kind of thing not because I believe it’s probably false, but because I believe a lot of it is probably true — and we have shown that we, by our natures, can’t handle this kind of truth. We will use it to construct ideologies that justify inhumanity with the authority of Science.
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
Art, Holism and Why People Believe
Link list with Rod Dreher, Andrew Sullivan leading back to Dana Gioia
I don’t think most people come to God (or most other core beliefs) through rational argumentation. They usually do the reasoning afterwards to explain to themselves and others why they believe. We experience faith, as we do almost everything else in life, holistically. We feel it with our emotions, intuition, and imagination as much as with our intellect. We even experience with our physical bodies.
The power of art is that it speaks to us in the fullness of our humanity. When the Church loses that capacity, it loses [its] ability to speak to most of humanity in its natural language. Theological arguments don’t even convince theologians to change their minds on a topic.
Posted in Daily Links and Notes
Leave a comment
Is Secularism just another version of “white people don’t think they have a culture?”
Is there a truly “natural” human being?
Ryan Bell wrote another blog post today. I’m enjoying his blog even though what I’m about to say is a sort of complaint. Maybe it’s my sick sense of enjoyment.
He uses “stepping into the void” and other language that seem to imagine that traveling from Christianity to atheism is like taking off a set of clothes, or stepping out of a room with smoke, or taking the cherry topping off of your cheesecake in order to finally discover the “you” under the “you” you used to know. It is again in a sense a search for the natural elephant borrowing from Jonathan Haidt’s imagery that the elephant is the unconscious self which is most of the “me” I am, while recognizing that the conscious self is just a small player (this too is not an unbiased idea but I think certainly has a lot of validity).
Bell talks about taking off “the god glasses”, again as if somehow his natural eyes can see straighter without the stuff that Christianity or religion put upon him. In all fairness he is undoing a Calvinist metaphor of using the Bible as corrective lenses, so he comes by this imagery honestly.
It strikes me, however, that this isn’t similar from the way white people talk about other people’s cultures, as if white people don’t have their own culture.
I read Rod Dreher’s little piece about culture and perpetual poverty where one person makes the observation that middle class life has a whole host of implicit, unwritten practices and expectations that actually act as an invisible barrier for upward economic mobility and inclusion in “the club” of the economic majority. This is, duh, what a culture is and how it works.
There is no such thing as a “natural” person, someone who is devoid of biases, culture, beliefs, and dare I say “religion”.
I imagine the journey Ryan Bell is on is from one room to another, from one set of clothes into another, from one type of air into another. White people have culture, and secular people have beliefs.
The Authentic Self
I can appreciate the idea of “the authentic self” but it tends to lean again towards the unadorned self or the self free from outside contamination. All that we have and are come from someone-where else. I received my genetic code from my parents. I absorbed culture from my context. The “authentic-self” is not a naked self. In some ways the word “authentic” is as abused as the word “literally“.
It is a bit amazing that in a context where we are perpetually reminded of the constructed nature of our existence that we imagine de-construction isn’t constructed.