Is Religion Child Abuse?

thinkingChristian.net

What can we conclude? This study suggests (though its methods cannot prove) that growing up Christian is a very good thing. Concerning Dawkins and his book, we can easily see that his attack is falsely based. We also see that this “rational” scientist ignored science and clear thinking to make the point he wanted to make.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Notes on Isaiah 6:9f

The great call of God to Isaiah is followed by what seems to be the most ridiculous calling. Isaiah is to speak the truth to a community that will never hear it. Jesus quotes this passage too.

Isaiah 6:9–10 (NET)

9 He said, “Go and tell these people: ‘Listen continually, but don’t understand! Look continually, but don’t perceive!’ 10 Make the hearts of these people calloused; make their ears deaf and their eyes blind! Otherwise they might see with their eyes and hear with their ears, their hearts might understand and they might repent and be healed.”

This reminded me of a piece by Rod Dreher on Phil Robertson’s comments about race.  Continue reading →

Posted in Understanding the Bible | Leave a comment

Plantinga’s Evolved Truth-Seeking Ape Challenge Challenged

Camels with hammers

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Ryan Bell Stepping into the Void

Ryan’s blog continues to produce.

In yesterday’s post he talks about two rooms and why he’s made the journey.  Belief and unbelief very much feel here to be questions of community. Which community does he prefer? Which is he drawn to? What does his status with these communities enable him to be, do, become?

What I discovered, especially over the past 5 years or so, is that there is a void staring me in the face, pulling me in. I am standing in a familiar, comfortable and comforting, well-lit room. On one wall is a door, standing open. It’s always been there—and always open—but the room I’m in is so much more inviting, so much more appealing. At least until recently. There are familiar people, familiar smells and sounds. But that door is always there. It’s unclear what is on the other side of the door. It is perfectly dark on the other side. The light in the room I’m in so completely illuminates the room that it only makes the blackness on the other side of the door more mystifying. In recently years the well-lit room has grown cold and limiting. The people are still lovely but many of them are content to have conversations that seem somehow trivial. The door has become more intriguing. What is in there? I’ve also felt an invitation from whatever is on the other side of the door and it beckons me toward it. In the past year I have stood in front of this door, the din of the room I’m in has faded into background noise and I’ve begun to see a faint light and hear the sounds of conversation beyond the doorframe.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Tagged , | Leave a comment

How to Be an Honest Atheist

Damon Linker

Existentialism differs from the greeting-card version of atheism so prevalent today, in taking its cue from the realization that life without God is hard.

It’s hard because human beings tend to be anxious animals, longing for someone or something to soothe us, to protect us from and relieve us of the worries wrapped up with our mortality. It’s hard because our lives and our loved ones matter to us more than we can possibly express — and the prospect of losing them for good in the annihilation of death is irrevocably terrifying. It’s hard because part of us wants to believe that we reside in a moral universe — that an immoral deed violates an intrinsic standard of right and wrong, even if the perpetrator eludes human punishment. And it’s hard, finally, because we crave good things for ourselves — many of which (fame, fortune, honor, glory) only the luckiest will ever acquire, and some of which (happiness unmixed with sorrow) no one will ever enjoy within the limits of our finite lives.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Why Doesn’t the Elephant Cure the Blind Men?

A telling of the old “elephant and the blind men” story, and one sharp commenter. 

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

What Stephen Colbert and St. Augustine Have In Common

America Magazine

First, Augustine tells catechists in On Christian Doctrine that they must delight their audience: “A hearer must be delighted, so that he can be gripped and made to listen.” This church father knew that it matters little whether one speaks the truth if one’s audience is not interested enough to pay attention. A boring presentation makes an audience less receptive and less likely to return, while a pleasing presentation renders an audience eager to listen and even to come back for more. In short, style makes a difference.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Religious Consumers in the Land of All-God, No-God, Which-God

Oishi Yoshio from Chushingura

All-God, No-God, Which-God

In Northern California people are all over the map when it comes to God. For some God is everywhere, in everything. You can’t step in dog-poop without touching God.

For others there is no God, not any kind of god. We are evolved mammals, products of physics and chance endowed with the mixed blessing of consciousness that brings us both wonder and suffering.

Relations among those who believe in a god but see that god as distinct from the material world are equally divided. There are hosts of things for these gods to disagree upon even if all believe there is finally only one mailbox for one big God who would hear our prayers or receive our praise. The different gods have different holy days, different codes of conduct, different dietary expectations.

The Reasonably Skeptical Urbane Majority

Polls tell us that a shrinking majority of Americans believe in “God” but pluralism has made them skeptical about many of the traditional religions that claim him.

We easily assume the ancient writings were uneven, primitive, infantile expressions that now through access to better and broader information are meant to be transcended. The outlines of ethics are clear to us even if we’re conflicted about the details. People are supposed to be good, kind and generous, helping the weak and shunning violence unless it’s absolutely necessary to preserve the assumed order that we see as self-evidently right. Surely all the enlightened people of the world mostly agree with us and its only the uneducated, primitive or the fundamentalistic who balk at how we all know the world should be administered.

Six Through Nine

While some fringe “freedom from religion” types might seek to get the 10 Commandments erased of courthouse walls most Americans are fairly comfortable with the reputation of morality found in many of these ten words. While they might be fuzzy about what all 10 commandments specifically say (more know the ingredients of the Big Mac), a review would probably produce near unanimity at least surrounding commandments 6 through 9. 

  • you shall not murder
  • you shall not you shall not commit adultery
  • you shall not steal
  • you shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.

Almost no one would wants these overthrown.

Some are Good Advice

Some of the other commandments might be accepted simply as good advice.

  • Honoring parents,
  • taking a day off each week,
  • not obsessing over your neighbor’s property

Most Americans I imagine would say that these too are helpful as long as we don’t get too legalistic about them.

The Troublesome Three Continue reading →

Posted in On the way to Sunday's sermon | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Rod Dreher: Theophany: The Day I came home for good

Link

I had begun reading The Divine Comedy around the time I started therapy, which was around the time I began observing the daily prayer rule. Going on the imaginative journey out of the dark wood with Dante, a spiritual and psychological pilgrimage through self-analysis and ascetic discipline, and towards learning how to re-order my understanding, brought the work my priest and my therapist were trying to do within me to astonishing fruition. I have been so ecstatic about Dante in this space recently because the power of art, working in conjunction with the power of prayer and the sacraments, and with the advice of a wise counselor, really did heal me. For example, when the pilgrim asks Marco the Lombard, in Purgatory, to tell him why the world is in such a bad state, Marco reminds him that blindness is in our nature, but that God gave us free will, and therefore power to change our fates, or at least control our reactions to events. This is nothing that my priest and my therapist hadn’t been telling me for some time … but there was something about hearing a penitent tell me these words along the pilgrim’s route with Dante and Virgil that made it catch fire inside my moral imagination.

This happened a lot. And without me quite realizing what was going on, God re-ordered my heart. It was confession, it was prayer, it was the liturgy, it was vespers, it was talking with my therapist, and it was, of course, reading Dante. One day I’ll write more about exactly how this came about; it’s why I am so on fire to talk to you readers about how Dante can save your life. Anyway, the point is, one day I woke up and knew that God the Father loved me. After that, everything fell into place. I could see clearly. The fear, the anxiety, the despair — all gone. And so was the chronic fatigue.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Louis Zamperini and Laura Hillenbrand

http://youtu.be/F0pulc6kDsk

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment