What does it mean that Jesus fulfills Scripture?

“And So Was Fulfilled What the Prophet Had Said”

This kind of language is common in the New Testament. Jesus did this or that in order that “scripture may be fulfilled”.

I used to hear these parts of the Bible in a way I never examined. I used to hear them as lists of proofs to convince doubters that Christianity is true and Jesus is God. I remember as a kid growing up in the church, going to Christian school, imagining that the reason people decided to be Christians, go to church, not beat their wives or neglect their children was because a prophet said something years before that came true in Jesus’ day.

It was like why we might or might not believe in Nostradamus or a fortune cookie or a horoscope.

Prophesies and fulfillments are all about proving to skeptics that a favorite person or group is right, or has insider information and the others are wrong. It’s about tribal warfare.

Reverse-Engineering Jesus

Later I would imagine that God kept a list. Better have Jesus go to Egypt, do this, do that, better route him this way because we’ve got an Old Testament check list to keep up with.

The trouble was that there was LOTS of stuff in the Old Testament and it hardly read like a straightforward formula which resulted in Jesus. Have you read Isaiah or Jeremiah from cover to cover?! You can see how Jesus’ followers SAW Jesus in Isaiah but if we were to simply try to construct Jesus from Isaiah things would be tough. We need to be a bit less judgmental towards the Pharisees and teachers of the law imagining that WE would have gotten it right even though they couldn’t see it. They knew their Bible pretty well.

Constructing Identity

Here’s another way to think about it.

There’s a lot of discussion about what is the self. Does the self exist? What is it? What is it made of? The answers aren’t as easy as you might assume and in fact these discussions have been around the world for quite a long time. It’s a rather interesting thing to talk about.

But let’s imagine what the gospel of Matthew is doing in chapter 2 with all of his Old Testament quoting. What is he trying to do? Why is he trying to connect Jesus to Israel and Jesus to the Old Testament?

Modern Americans love to imaging our “selves” or identities as things we freely construct. Why have my gender determined by my genes or my genitalia? Some Americans think there is deep within us a true “self” that we need to discover and then assert against imposing and impinging powers against us like social norms. We play with these ideas all the time.

Ancients of course far more often saw themselves as receiving identity and figuring out how to fulfill a received self. What am I to do as the son or daughter of this parent or ancestor?

Locating Jesus in the Story Continue reading →

Posted in Understanding the Bible | Tagged | 2 Comments

Julian Bagggini on the self

Similar to the TED talk 

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

The Tragedy of the American Military

James Fallows

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Bodies of Babies Found in MA Home

NYTimes

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

All the Single Ladies

The Atlantic

Recent years have seen an explosion of male joblessness and a steep decline in men’s life prospects that have disrupted the “romantic market” in ways that narrow a marriage-minded woman’s options: increasingly, her choice is between deadbeats (whose numbers are rising) and playboys (whose power is growing).

No one has been hurt more by the arrival of the post-industrial economy than the stubbornly large pool of men without higher education. An analysis by Michael Greenstone, an economist at MIT, reveals that, after accounting for inflation, male median wages have fallen by 32 percent since their peak in 1973, once you account for the men who have stopped working altogether. The Great Recession accelerated this imbalance. Nearly three-quarters of the 7.5 million jobs lost in the depths of the recession were lost by men, making 2010 the first time in American history that women made up the majority of the workforce. Men have since then regained a small portion of the positions they’d lost—but they remain in a deep hole, and most of the jobs that are least likely ever to come back are in traditionally male-dominated sectors, like manufacturing and construction.

The implications are extraordinary. If, in all sectors of society, women are on the ascent, and if gender parity is actually within reach, this means that a marriage regime based on men’s overwhelming economic dominance may be passing into extinction. As long as women were denied the financial and educational opportunities of men, it behooved them to “marry up”—how else would they improve their lot? (As Maureen Dowd memorably put it in her 2005 book, Are Men Necessary?, “Females are still programmed to look for older men with resources, while males are still programmed to look for younger women with adoring gazes.”) Now that we can pursue our own status and security, and are therefore liberated from needing men the way we once did, we are free to like them more, or at least more idiosyncratically, which is how love ought to be, isn’t it?

Indeed, Siberia today is suffering such an acute “man shortage” (due in part to massive rates of alcoholism) that both men and women have lobbied the Russian parliament to legalize polygamy. In 2009, The Guardian cited Russian politicians’ claims that polygamy would provide husbands for “10 million lonely women.” In endorsing polygamy, these women, particularly those in remote rural areas without running water, may be less concerned with loneliness than with something more pragmatic: help with the chores. Caroline Humphrey, a Cambridge University anthropologist who has studied the region, said women supporters believed the legalization of polygamy would be a “godsend,” giving them “rights to a man’s financial and physical support, legitimacy for their children, and rights to state benefits.”

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

The Formula for Sitcoms

The Atlantic

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

2014 in review

The WordPress.com stats helper monkeys prepared a 2014 annual report for this blog.

Here’s an excerpt:

Madison Square Garden can seat 20,000 people for a concert. This blog was viewed about 66,000 times in 2014. If it were a concert at Madison Square Garden, it would take about 3 sold-out performances for that many people to see it.

Click here to see the complete report.

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Losing the Self

The Atlantic

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

How God Died

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment

Caputo on Christianity and pluralism

http://www.christiancentury.org/article/2014-12/restless-search-truth

Posted in Daily Links and Notes | Leave a comment